How Drinking Can Be Good For You
10 Aug
My husband’s family in Ireland is an adherent of the Irish temperance movement known as the Pioneers. So it was a surprise to find his Uncle Miah sipping an Irish whiskey after dinner at his house in County Cork. “Doctor’s orders,” he said with a sheepish shrug. Miah had suffered a heart attack a few months earlier, and his doctor suggested an after dinner dram of whiskey would be good medicine.
That’s not just Blarney. More than 60 separate studies find that drinking alcohol in moderation is good for your heart. And the good news doesn’t end there—moderate drinking is connected to lower risk of Alzheimer’s disease, diabetes and stroke, as well as weight loss. One Tuscan study even linked light to moderate red wine drinking to improved sexual function in women.
Scientists are still unraveling the reasons why drinking can be good for you—everything from the alcohol itself to its concentration of antioxidants may be the reason. Or it may even be some complex interaction of many different components. Some conflicting research says the same benefits can be had from grape juice, while other studies find that’s not the case. There is even some evidence to suggest that moderate drinking can slow declines in cognitive function brought on by old age. But on the other side of the coin, heavy drinking has been linked to a faster decline.
The Antioxidant Theory
A lot of research about alcohol’s benefits has focused on antioxidants, present in sizable amounts in certain kinds of alcohol, including whiskey, red wine and darker beers, and to a lesser amount in lagers and white wine. Antioxidants are thought to protect cells from free radicals—potentially harmful molecules your body produces when breaking down food or in reaction to environmental exposures like tobacco smoke and radiation. Scientists say free radicals can damage cells, and may play a role in heart disease and cancer, among other diseases.
Resveratrol, a particular type of antioxidant present in red wine, has been much discussed for its apparent ability to reduce inflammation in the arteries. It may have other important functions as well. New research on mice published in the July issue of the American Journal of Pathology links resveratrol to a shrinkage of abnormal blood vessels in the eye, yielding a promising breakthrough in dealing with leading causes of blindness. However, since the dose given to mice would be the equivalent of several bottles of wine, it would likely be given in pill form.
The Mediterranean Connection
While numerous studies, including a recent one done by French scientists at the Center for Cardiovascular Disease Prevention, point to better overall health among moderate drinkers, most researchers admit that the drinking may be a signifier of an overall healthier lifestyle, rather than a cause itself.
Much fuss was made, several years back, of the inclusion of wine in the so-called Mediterranean Diet, but it was important to note that the diet is low in saturated fat and high in whole grains and fruits and vegetables—all things that we know lead to better overall health.
The French study, published in the European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, questioned nearly 150,000 Parisians about their drinking habits, then subjected them to a battery of tests.
Moderate drinkers of both sexes were found to have low body mass index, heart rate, good blood sugar levels, lower “bad” cholesterol and higher “good” cholesterol. Men also showed lower stress and depression scores. Further, moderate and low drinkers displayed better health status than did the never-drinkers. Researchers concluded that “moderate alcohol consumption may represent a marker of higher social level, superior health status and lower cardiovascular risk.”
Moderation is Key
The key to realizing better health through drinking alcohol, as in so many things in life, is moderation. A study published in the New England Journal of Medicine linked drinking as little as the equivalent of a half glass of wine, three to four days a week, to a sizable reduction in risk for heart attack. Drinking more didn’t improve health further, and it didn’t matter what type of alcohol (wine, beer, whiskey, etc.) was consumed.
Currently, the U.S. government defines moderate drinking as one 12-ounce beer, a five-ounce glass of wine or 1.5 ounces of liquor per day for a woman and up two drinks per day for a man. Each of these servings has about the same amount of alcohol and the same number of calories. The National Institutes of Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism recently released new guidelines expected to be adopted by the U.S. government, defining low-risk drinking as no more than seven drinks a week for women and fourteen for men, with no more than three drinks in any one single day for women and four for men.
Dangers of Heavy Drinking
For all the beneficial effects scientists have determined can be gained through moderate alcohol consumption, this is one area where you can definitely have too much of a good thing.
Many studies link excessive alcohol consumption to cancer—particularly breast, liver and colon cancer—and stroke, among other health problems. And for those who cannot restrict their consumption to moderate drinking, the dangers of excessive drinking far outweigh the possible benefits. Excessive drinking is also implicated in unintentional injury from car accidents, falls and drowning.
Experts advise enjoying your drinks with food—never on an empty stomach—and drinking slowly to avoid intoxication. Of course, you should never drink alcohol if you’ll be driving, and double check that any medication you are taking is safe to be consumed with alcohol.
Odds are prescribing a drink a day won’t be the first thing your doctor thinks of to combat heart disease. But if you’re like Uncle Miah, it might be worth exploring with your physician. If you already enjoy a few drinks a week, relax. And as they say in Ireland when posing a toast, Slainte, which means good health!
Jeanne O’Brien Coffey
Contributing Editor
New England Health Advisory




Recent Comments